Monday, August 8, 2016

Conor's Evidence Based Inclusion - Outside The Regular Classroom


Conor, with severe autism and profound intellectual disability,  has loved his time in school and this year faces his last year before he turns 21. He has not always loved school though.  Like all NB students he started school in the regular classroom but was not comfortable in that location. As grade 2  got underway the challenges of he regular classroom overwhelmed him and he came home each day with self inflicted bite marks on his hands and wrists as shown in this picture:


I had visited the school regularly to pick him up after school and had seen him uncomfortable with the noise as the day ended but did not realize that he had been having difficulty with the sensory and other challenges of the regular classroo until the biting started in grade 2. It was so persistent that we asked him to be moved to a location outside the regular classroom where he could work with an aide. The staff on the scene at the school could see the self harm.  Once he was moved the biting and self harm STOPPED.  

Conor has received his primary instruction outside the regular classroom ever since.  He interacts or has the opportunity to interact with other students in activities including his favorite activity swimming at the Nashwaaksis Middle School swimming pool.  He has been very happy in school with these evidence based arrangements and every summer misses school. To help with his anxiety as he waits for school to resume each year he changes the number on the white board above reducing it by one day as soon as he gets up.

Everyone, including me, likes the concept of inclusion.  What's not to like about it? As a simple statement of principle there is nothing wrong with it.  In New Brunswick though the concept of inclusion has been replaced by an ideological devotion to placement of all students in the regular classroom.  That simplistic, non evidence based belief has dominated the education of NB students. Some "community" activists have fought hard to force all students in to the regular classroom and they have had great influence in doing so. The result is that some children, including SOME children with autism, who can not function in the regular classroom can actually be harmed by ignoring the reality that the LOCATION in which they are placed can be overwhelming for them.

Gordon Porter is the iconic leader of NB's extreme inclusion movement.  He has been given many awards for pushing his non evidence based approach to inclusive education an approach he summarized, "as simple, so simple" in a previous presentation in Newfoundland:



CORNER BROOK — Gordon Porter believes inclusion is the most natural thing in the world. The educator and director of Inclusive Education Initiatives presented a session on inclusive education at the Greenwood Inn and Suites on Thursday. Porter, who is also the editor of the Inclusive Education Canada website inclusiveeducation.ca, spoke to parents, educators and agency professionals who deal with children with special needs at the pre-conference for the Newfoundland and Labrador Association for Community Living Conference taking place in the city today and Saturday. The session was sponsored by the Community Inclusion Initiative. 

 Porter’s session revolved around the theme of parents and teachers working together to make inclusion work.“It means kids go to their neighbourhood schools with kids their own age in regular classes,” said Porter.“If you’re seven years, old you go to the school just down the street. You go in a class with other seven-year-olds, and you’re supported if you have extra needs. “It’s so simple, it’s that simple,” said Porter."   
                                                                                 
- Inclusion in the classroom ‘simple,’ says educator, Western Star, Diane Crocker, April 12,  2012

The only reason inclusion is simple, so simple, for Gordon Porter and his devoted followers, is that they ignore evidence to the contrary.  Some challenged children can prosper in the regular classroom, some can not, for some it is harmful. It is necessary to look at the evidence of what is best for particular students. My son's evidence, his biting of his hands in the regular classroom, the cessation of the biting AS SOON as he was removed to a quieter location outside the regular classroom, his love for school, including activity with other students outside the regular classroom,  is simply ignored.  

Thankfully, as his parents, with knowledge of his behaviors and his autism disorder, and with the help of education staff who could see the harm the  simple inclusion philosophy caused our son, we were able to accommodate our son's education needs outside of the regular classroom.  

A big THANK YOU to the education staff at Nashwaaksis Memorial school who could see the evidence that the harm of the regular classroom caused  our son and helped us  despite the near cult like grip that the Gordon Porter, non evidence based philosophy has on NB students.      

Monday, August 1, 2016

Adult Autism Advocacy Events at the New Brunswick Legislature October 22 and 29 2016


Autism advocacy events Saturday October 22, 29 NB Legislature Grounds Fredericton. Time to Act, Time to be Heard!

The early intervention program in NB has been recognized internationally. It happened because of autism advocacy led by parents. The autism trained TA's and resource teachers also happened because of parent led autism advocacy. ... Services for neither age range is perfect but nothing has been accomplished on adult care and treatment. The priority as stated on the pinned commentary and post from CBC NB Votes 2010 is to advocate for adult autism services, specifically an autism network with a central facility in Fredericton for those needing permanent care and to provide consultation and oversight to a network of autism specific group homes around the province. It is now time for the members of Autism Advocacy NB to become more active. To that end anyone interested in actually advocating for the adult autism network and participating in the October 22 and 29 events can contact me at hldoherty5463@gmail.com.

The principles of a humane, evidence based, modern adult autism care and treatment network were enunciated by Professor Emeritus (Psychology) and NB Autism Expert Paul McDonnell in a 2010 CBC interview: 



"Paul McDonnell, September, 2010
"Our greatest need at present is to develop services for adolescents and adults. What is needed is a range of residential and non-residential services and these services need to be staffed with behaviourally trained supervisors and therapists. In the past we have had the sad spectacle of individuals with autism being sent off to institutional settings such as the Campbellton psychiatric hospital, hospital wards, prisons, and even out of the country at enormous expense and without any gains to the individual, the family or the community.
We need an enhanced group home system throughout the province in which homes would be linked directly to a major centre that could provide ongoing training, leadership and supervision. That major centre could also provide services for those who are mildly affected as well as permanent residential care and treatment for the most severely affected. Such a secure centre would not be based on a traditional "hospital" model but should, itself, be integrated into the community in a dynamic manner, possibly as part of a private residential development.The focus must be on education, positive living experiences, and individualized curricula. The key to success is properly trained professionals and staff."

Sunday, July 24, 2016

Bumping Into Shawn Graham - A Premier Who Made A Difference For NB's Autistic Children



Above Shawn Graham commits to allocate resources to autism children in New Bruswick, 2010

Below Shawn Graham and late Fredericton MP Andy Scott who advocated for autism services in Ottawa spend some time with the kids at Autism Intervention Services, Fredericton




On the way back from a visit to the Eagle's Nest with Conor I stopped to grab Conor a pop at a service station.  I didn't recognize the gentleman standing in front of me until he turned around and said hello.  It was a genuine pleasure to bump into Shawn Graham a genuinely nice guy and a premier who did much to help autistic children in NB.   

I know first hand that he expanded on the early intervention autism services begun by former premier Bernard Lord and provided an unambiguous commitment to train 400 teacher aides and resource teachers at the UNB-CEL Autism Intervention Training progam that had received international recognition. His specific commitment was to train 100 per year for 4 years and he kept that promise despite intense pressure from some in the Department of Education who saw career possibilities for themselves by bringing the program in house under their direction.   

NB is a small province and sometimes you bump into people of prominence. That is all well and good.  When it is a premier who did so much for autistic children it is a real treat and makes my day.

Friday, July 22, 2016

Another Conor Seizure Today; Fortunately It Happened On A Cushy Living Room Couch With Dad Right There


Conor very happy on Friday, April 29 2016.  This Friday things were a bit
different as Conor suffered a grand mal, tonic clonic seizure. On the positive 
side it happened on a cushy couch in our living room with Dad within arm's 
reach and Conor himself handled it well. It was still scary though.

At 3:35 today I had just finished a phone discussion on a legal matter and returned to the living room where I have a table and my laptop so I could do some work.  Conor was sitting directly in front of me on one of 2 living room couches.  As I sat down Conor's head kicked back and his eyes rolled back in his head.  He began convulsing  violently.  Fortunately the couch had large soft cushions and Conor suffered no impact to his head. He also turned to his side himself so that any fluids drained out without him choking and he then put his knees on the floor and bent over the cushion seats so he was not at any risk. I was there holding him throughout and timed the process.  The worst convulsions last between 45-60 seconds although his body still jerked for awhile and he did not regain bodily control or speech for a few more minutes.  ..  Not the first time I have been there for a Conor seizure.  It never gets real easy but it is not quite as scary as the first couple of times.  That said the location and an adult presence (me) assured a degree of safety that may not always be around for him and the outcome might be different on some future occasion.  ... For now though Conor is resting comfortably on the other living room couch .. eating pizza.  And life is good.

Friday, July 1, 2016

I Will Not Quit Fighting for Humane Services for NB Adults with Severe Autism - I Thank Ernie Steeves and All Who Join the Fight




Left  to Right: Brian MacDonald, Jane Mullin, Glen Savoie, Crystal Kelley,
 Ernie Steeves, Conor Doherty, Harold Doherty Stewart Fairgrieve, Charles Leblanc

It was a privilege yesterday to meet and enjoy the support of Ernie Steeves, Brian MacDonald, Glen Savoie and Stewart Fairgrieve in the NB Legislature fighting for decent autism services. Jane Mullin, Crystal Kelly and Charles LeBlanc  also took part outside.  Unfortunately Ernie Steeves motion seeking to improve autism services was thoroughly gutted by the Liberals of Donald Arseneault, and Stephen Horsman.  It is  important to say THANK YOU to those like  Ernie Steeves, Brian MacDonald, Glen Savoie and Stewart Fairgrieve who have made great efforts to improve autism services in New Brunswick. 

Although I was very ticked off  yesterday at Stephen Horsman, the MLA for my riding  and Minister of the newly named (yet again) Family and Childrens Services I bear him no ill will. I also have to give him some support.  As a parent who was involved with other parents in the successful advocacy for the establishment of NB's internationally recognized early intervention program and school services I know autism advocacy is not easy for anyone even a Deputy Premier and cabinet minister.   And Minister Stephen Horsman has contributed in his own way by walking with autistic children in Superhero walks and helping cut the cake for the reopening of the Autism Connections Resource center.  

It will obviously be necessary once again to fight entrenched interests to try and estblish the Adult Autism Center and Network that NBers with severe autism need so badly.  In the meantime many severely autistic adults will be banished to the Restigouche Psychiatric Hospital in Minister Donald Arseneault's riding on our northern border with Quebec.  

It will be important to gather the support of friends to overcome the entrenched interests in the Liberal Party that want all of NB's severely autistic adults to live in Minister Donald Arseneault's riding at the Restigouche Psychiatric Hospital.  

Wednesday, June 29, 2016

NB Adult Autism Residential Center – Information Protest at the Legislature – Weather & Autism Related Circumstances Permitting Thursday, June 30, 2016


My son Conor and I will, weather and autism circumstances permitting, be conducting an adult autism center information protest this Thursday June 30 at the Legislature. 

New Brunswick has received world recognition for it’s bilingual early autism intervention programs and families have moved to NB from elsewhere in Canada to obtain early autism  intervention services for their autistic children.  We have also made very significant gains in education with hundreds of autism trained education assistants and BCBA qualified resource teachers and assistants.  Despite the expertise developed in autism services successive governments have refused to develop the autism center and network recommended by NB autism expert Paul McDonnell in a 2010 CBC interview even though Department of  Social Development Media Representative Mark Barbour in a 2011 interview with then Aquinian journalist/student, now CBC journalist Karissa Donkin stated that the PNB wanted to develop an adult autism residential center to provide care for those with severe autism:

“There is a need for more specialized services for autistic youth and adults, whose behaviours or conditions are severely impaired.

“These individuals require services and supports designed to specifically meet their high care needs.”

The province wants to build an autism residential facility, which would provide permanent care for severely autistic adults who can’t live on their own, Barbour said.”
                                                                                                                                               


The expertise to provide the specialized services for autistic youth and adults exists in Fredericton where the early intervention programs were developed with UNB-CEL autism intervention programs, assistance from UNB Psychology were available and willing. The bilingual training has proven very effective.  But autistic adults have been sent far from the largest segment of the NB population at the Campbellton Regional Psychiatric Hospital on our Northern border with Quebec and in Spurwink, Maine in the United States.  Such separation from families can be harmful as discussed by NB autism expert Paul McDonnell in a 2010 CBC interview


“Autistic adults are often sent to privately run group homes or in extreme cases, sent to psychiatric care in Campbellton or  out of province.

“It’s fairly expensive to put people in group homes and if you have to send people out of the province then it’s much, much more expensive,” McDonnell said.
“If they’re placed far away from their families,  that creates a lot of hardship as well. A lot of people aren’t functioning at the level they could. They’re simply not having the quality of life they should be having.”
McDonnell thinks the province needs to train people to be prepared to deal with adults with severe behavioural challenges.
“They should have stimulating recreational, educational programs. That is absolutely essential.
“That’s what we need to aim towards is setting up a system where we have some really well-trained people.”

Harold L Doherty
Conor’s Dad
506 447-1592

Tuesday, June 28, 2016

NB Has Gone Backwards In Understanding and Commitment to Meeting Adult Autism Needs Since 2011


The province wants to build an autism residential facility, which would provide 
permanent care for severely autistic adults who can’t live on their own.
Mark Barbour, NB Department of Social Development spokesperson,
A Place for Conor, The Aquinian, by Karissa Donkin, March 24, 2011

Many politicians love to participate in Superhero Walks for Autism.  They get to actually have fun, along with the children on the walk, and then pose for publicity photos which imply that they are knowledgeable about autism and are working on the behalf of persons with autism.  Unfortunately such walks do not create any real autism awareness, or lead to needs being met; particularly needs of autistic adults.

In meetings with the Gallant Government's 2 Ministers of Social Development to date, including one held with Minister Stephen Horsman yesterday, there was civility and apparent understanding of the need to address adult autism needs.  It was clear yesterday though that no steps had been taken in addressing adult autism needs in the past year since I, along with NB autism expert Paul McDonnell and fellow autism parent advocate Cynthia Bartlett, met with then Minister of SD Cathy Rogers.  Minister Horsman yesterday actually made statements endorsing the role of the Regional Psychiatric Hopital in Campbellton and asked whether autism specific services were needed. An indication of the extent to which those statements indicate a regression in understanding of, and commitment to providing services to meet the needs of, autistic adults can be gleaned by reading information in a March 2011 article by Karissa Donkin then a journalist with the Aquinian.

On March 24 2011 an excellent article written in the Aquinian by then student Karissa Donkin (now a journalist with CBC after a tour with the Brunswick News papers) detailed the need for adult autism services in NB.  The following excerpt is from that article.  In the article Mark Barbour, then a Department of Social Developent spokesperson, stated very clearly that more had to be done to help autistic adults  including provisio of autism specific  services.  He also stated that the Province of NB wanted to build an autistic adult residential facility to provide permanent care for severely autistic adults who can't live on their own:

"Autism is a developmental disorder that affects a person’s communication and social skills. The severity of the disorder ranges from the severe form that Conor has to Asperger’s, a more mild form depicted in movies like Rainman. The Centre for Disease Control and Prevention says one in 110 children have autism. [The CDC now estimates 1 in 68 - HLD]
New Brunswick provides care both in a patient’s home and in residential facilities for more than 6,250 adults under 65 with disabilities, including autism, says Department of Social Development spokesman Mark Barbour.
But Barbour admits the province needs to do more to help autistic adults.
“There is a need for more specialized services for autistic youth and adults, whose behaviours or conditions are severely impaired.
“These individuals require services and supports designed to specifically meet their high care needs.”
The province wants to build an autism residential facility, which would provide permanent care for severely autistic adults who can’t live on their own, Barbour said.
Not only is the current system not comprehensive enough for adults with varying degrees of autism, but it’s also expensive, says child psychologist and autism expert Dr. Paul McDonnell.

Autistic adults are often sent to privately run group homes or in extreme cases, sent to psychiatric care in Campbellton or out of province.
“It’s fairly expensive to put people in group homes and if you have to send people out of the province then it’s much, much more expensive,” McDonnell said.
“If they’re placed far away from their families, that creates a lot of hardship as well. A lot of people aren’t functioning at the level they could. They’re simply not having the quality of life they should be having.”
McDonnell thinks the province needs to train people to be prepared to deal with adults with severe behavioural challenges.
“They should have stimulating recreational, educational programs. That is absolutely essential.

“That’s what we need to aim towards is setting up a system where we have some really well-trained people.”